I was incredibly excited about this book. I ran out and purchased it the day it came out, because I saw it advertised on a blog that I follow, read the first pages on Amazon and was hooked. There were a few reasons, however, why I didn’t end up liking this novel.
1) Prose
Mafi has the potential to be a very wonderful writer. Some of her prose had me completely head-over-heels with how wonderful and lyrical it was. Other lines, however, completely missed the mark – to the point that I would have to stop, think, and read the line over again. And that made for a difficult read.
By the time I decided to review this novel, I was almost finished – my examples aren’t the best/worst in the book, but they should give you an idea of what I’m talking about.
Lines I loved:
- I’ve searched the whole world for all the right words but my mouth is full of nothing.
- He flexes his jaw. Pries his lips open. Lies to me over and over again. “I’m okay.”
Lines I hated:
- Heat rushes up my neck and I fall off a ladder holding a paintbrush dipped in red. (I litereally had to stop and wonder when they started painting. I still can’t figure out what the paintbrush would symbolize.)
- The sun is revolving around the moon when he responds. (What does this mean? Was it getting dark? Did she feel like a lot of time had passed? Why would the sun be revolving around the moon?)
Lines I’m unsure about:
- His lips are spelling secrets and my ears are spilling ink, staining my skin with his stories. (I think I like how this begins, but I have no idea what she means by “ears… spilling ink.” Besides sounding poetic, it makes no sense. Maybe I watch too many horror films, but I envisioned this quite literally.)
2) Unoriginality
I felt like the first chapters of this book were the strongest and the best. There was a lot left to the imagination as to what was going on in the world and in the story, and I found the set-up intriguing. But the further I went along, the more I was disappointed – mostly by the whole X-Men theme.
I was explaining the book to my fiance one night in bed, describing the main character and what was happening to her. He raised an eyebrow and said, “So, she’s like Rogue?”
Yes, the main character was exactly like Rogue. Denied by family and friends, she is doomed to live her life alone – that is, until she meets friend and saviour Adam and falls head-over-heels for him in a completely unrealistic love.
By the end of the book we discover that there are all sorts of people with different mutant powers, collected in an institution to help and teach them. Sound familiar?
3) The Bella Syndrome
I’m not sure if this syndrome started with Bella, or if its just easier to pick out. Basically, the main character of this book is all unworthy and weak until she meets the pretty boy and they fall in love and are all over each other for really no reason other than to have a love story in the middle of a YA book. I wished that Juliette was a bit more dimensional, and that the love between herself and Adam had more tension and less of, well, everything. Not once did I relate to either character, nor did I feel like it even made sense for them to be at the point in their relationship that they suddenly were at.
I suppose I’m being a bit brutal with my review, but I think it’s mostly because I felt so betrayed. The beginning is honestly really good. There are other things I really enjoyed – the antagonist, for example – Warner is far more interesting than any of the other characters, with his lust for blood, need for love and obvious daddy issues. I haven’t yet decided if I liked the whole cross-out thing the book had going on, but I appreciated its originality. The numbers, however, I found rather irritating by the end (you’ll have to read in order to know what I’m talking about.) And despite my complaints, the book is still worth the read. As I said, the author does have a good amount of talent, and I really enjoyed many of her lines.
I give this book a generous 3/5 stars!





















